EFEarnings Feed

Nov 23, 2025 · 7 min read

Insider Buying Trends by Sector: Where Executives Are Putting Their Money

Analysis of insider buying patterns across market sectors. Find out which industries see the most executive confidence and what it means for investors.

Insider buying varies dramatically across sectors. Some industries consistently see executives purchasing their own stock. Others rarely do. Understanding these patterns helps you interpret individual Form 4 filings in context.

We analyzed insider buying activity to identify which sectors see the most executive purchases and what drives the differences.

Insider Buying by Sector

Here's how sectors rank by insider buying activity, based on open market purchases (transaction code P):

Highest Insider Buying

1. Financial Services

Banks, insurance companies, and financial institutions consistently lead in insider buying. Why:

  • Bank executives often have significant personal wealth
  • Financial stocks are volatile, creating buying opportunities
  • Regulatory scrutiny makes insider activity more visible
  • Bank CEOs face pressure to demonstrate confidence

Typical pattern: Cluster buying after sector selloffs, especially during banking crises

2. Energy

Oil, gas, and energy company insiders buy frequently:

  • Commodity price volatility creates entry points
  • Insider purchases signal confidence despite oil price swings
  • Many energy executives have multi-generational industry ties
  • Activist investors often become insiders and buy

Typical pattern: Buying increases when oil prices crash

3. Healthcare and Biotech

Biotech in particular sees sporadic but significant insider buying:

  • Executives buy before expected FDA decisions
  • Founders often buy during capital raises
  • Clinical trial timelines create information asymmetry
  • Many biotech insiders are former scientists with conviction

Typical pattern: Buying clusters before binary events (FDA decisions, trial readouts)

4. Industrial/Manufacturing

Steady insider buying in traditional industries:

  • Family-owned companies with management stakes
  • Long-tenured executives with deep company knowledge
  • Cyclical businesses that create buying opportunities
  • Conservative management cultures that favor ownership

Typical pattern: Counter-cyclical buying during economic downturns

Lowest Insider Buying

1. Technology (Large Cap)

Despite creating enormous wealth, large tech companies see relatively little open market insider buying:

  • Executives already have massive stock grants
  • Diversification is the priority, not accumulation
  • Stock compensation makes purchases redundant
  • High valuations make buying psychologically difficult

Typical pattern: Buying increases only during major selloffs

2. Consumer Discretionary

Retail and consumer companies see less insider buying:

  • Many executives come from non-equity backgrounds
  • Higher management turnover
  • Consumer trends are harder to predict
  • Compensation structures favor cash

Typical pattern: Sporadic, often around activist situations

3. Utilities

The quietest sector for insider buying:

  • Stable, predictable businesses
  • Limited upside potential
  • Dividend-focused investors, including insiders
  • Regulatory constraints on returns

Typical pattern: Minimal activity; any buying is notable

Why Sectors Differ

Several factors explain sectoral differences in insider buying:

Compensation Structure

High insider buying sectors often have:

  • Lower base salaries relative to equity
  • More executives promoted from within
  • Longer average tenure
  • Founder involvement

Low insider buying sectors often have:

  • High stock-based compensation
  • More executive turnover
  • Shorter average tenure
  • Professional management from outside

Volatility

More volatile sectors create more buying opportunities. When stocks swing 30-50%, insiders can buy at meaningful discounts. Stable sectors rarely offer these entry points.

Valuation

Lower-valued sectors see more buying. Financial services and energy often trade at single-digit P/E ratios, making purchases feel more justified. High-growth tech at 50x earnings is psychologically harder to buy.

Industry Culture

Some industries have cultures of ownership. Bank CEOs are expected to own significant stock. Tech executives are expected to hold their grants but not necessarily add. These cultural norms persist.

Regulatory Environment

Heavily regulated industries (banks, utilities) face more scrutiny on insider transactions. Paradoxically, this can increase transparency and confidence in the data.

Timing Patterns

Insider buying isn't evenly distributed through time:

Earnings Season Effect

Insider buying clusters around the start and end of earnings windows:

  • Pre-blackout buying: Purchases right before blackout periods begin
  • Post-earnings buying: Purchases right after results release

Blackout periods (typically 2 weeks before earnings through 48 hours after) prevent trading. Watch for buying right after blackouts lift.

Crisis Buying

Sector-wide crises trigger waves of insider buying:

  • Banking crisis (2023): Regional bank executives bought heavily
  • Oil crash (2020): Energy insider buying spiked
  • Tech correction (2022): First major tech insider buying in years

These cluster events often mark sector bottoms.

Year-End Activity

December and January see elevated insider buying:

  • Tax planning (buying before year-end)
  • Bonus season (deploying compensation)
  • New year optimism
  • 10b5-1 plan establishments

Sector-Specific Signals

What constitutes a strong signal varies by sector:

Financial Services

Strong signals:

  • CEO buying $1M+ in open market
  • Multiple executives buying during crisis
  • Board member buying after regulatory announcement

Weaker signals:

  • Directors buying small amounts
  • Buying during calm markets
  • Single insider purchases

Energy

Strong signals:

  • Buying when oil is below $60/barrel
  • Multiple executives adding positions
  • Activist investors accumulating

Weaker signals:

  • Buying when oil prices are high
  • Small director purchases
  • Options exercises only

Healthcare/Biotech

Strong signals:

  • Founder buying before FDA decision
  • CEO buying after clinical failure (contrarian)
  • Multiple insiders adding during capital raise

Weaker signals:

  • Small purchases by non-scientist executives
  • Post-approval buying (news already out)
  • Single small-cap purchases

Technology

Strong signals:

  • Any open market buying (rare in this sector)
  • Buying after major selloff
  • Multiple executives acting together

Weaker signals:

  • RSU exercises (routine)
  • Buying at all-time highs
  • Director purchases only

Using Sector Context

When you see an insider purchase, contextualize it:

Step 1: Check Sector Norms

Is insider buying common in this sector? A bank CEO buying stock is normal. A utility CEO buying is notable.

Step 2: Compare to Recent Activity

Is this purchase unusual relative to recent sector activity? During the 2022 tech correction, any tech insider buying was significant because it was so rare.

Step 3: Size the Opportunity

What's the setup? Insider buying during a sector crisis (like banking in 2023) carries more weight than buying during calm periods.

Step 4: Look for Clusters

Are other companies in the sector seeing insider buying? Sector-wide cluster buying can signal industry-wide opportunity.

Current Trends

Sector insider buying trends shift over time. Factors to monitor:

Interest Rate Sensitivity

Higher rates have historically:

  • Increased financial sector insider buying (banks benefit)
  • Decreased tech/growth insider buying (valuation compression)
  • Mixed impact on real estate (varies by subsector)

Economic Cycle

Where are we in the cycle?

  • Early recovery: Cyclical sector insider buying increases
  • Late cycle: Defensive sector insider buying increases
  • Recession: Counter-cyclical buying opportunities emerge

Sector Rotation

Money flows between sectors. Watch for:

  • New insider buying in out-of-favor sectors
  • Decreased buying in recently hot sectors
  • Divergence between stock prices and insider sentiment

Building a Sector Watchlist

Create a systematic approach to tracking sector insider activity:

High-Value Sectors to Monitor

  1. Financials: Most consistent insider buying data
  2. Energy: Strong contrarian signals
  3. Small-cap healthcare: Binary event opportunities
  4. Industrials: Cyclical timing signals

Lower-Priority Sectors

  1. Large-cap tech: Too much noise from equity compensation
  2. Utilities: Rare activity, less informative
  3. Consumer staples: Minimal insider trading

Weekly Sector Scan

  1. Check Form 4 filings by sector
  2. Note any cluster buying patterns
  3. Compare to sector price action
  4. Flag unusual activity for research

Summary

Insider buying patterns vary significantly across sectors:

  • Financial services and energy see the most insider buying
  • Tech and utilities see the least open market purchases
  • Crisis buying during sector selloffs is the strongest signal
  • Sector context matters when interpreting individual purchases

A bank CEO buying stock is expected. A tech CEO buying stock is news. Understanding these norms helps you identify truly notable insider activity.

Track Insider Activity by Sector

Monitor insider buying patterns across the market.

Create a free Earnings Feed account to track Form 4 filings and build sector-specific watchlists.

Explore more: