BUTLER JOHN C JR 4
4 · NACCO INDUSTRIES INC · Filed Feb 18, 2026
Research Summary
AI-generated summary of this filing
NACCO CEO John C. Butler Jr Receives Award, Surrenders Shares
What Happened
- John C. Butler Jr., President & CEO and a director of NACCO Industries (NC), was granted 39,630 shares under the company’s Executive Long-Term Incentive Plan (LTIP) on 2026-02-17. On the same date he surrendered 8,777 shares to the company to satisfy tax withholding obligations related to that award. No dollar prices were reported in the Form 4 (amounts listed as N/A).
Key Details
- Transaction dates: 2026-02-17 (reported on Form 4 filed 2026-02-18).
- Grant: 39,630 shares (code A — award/acquisition under LTIP; footnote F1).
- Disposal: 8,777 shares surrendered for tax withholding (code F; described as a cashless surrender to satisfy tax withholding; footnote F4).
- Prices/values: Not reported (N/A) in the filing.
- Shares owned after transaction: Not specified in this filing.
- Filing timeliness: Filed the day after the transactions (no indication of a late filing).
- Relevant footnotes: F1 (LTIP award), F4 (cashless surrender to cover tax withholding). Several other footnotes describe holdings in trusts/IRAs and disclaimers of beneficial ownership for certain family/partnership interests.
Context
- This is an equity award grant combined with a routine tax-withholding surrender, not an open-market purchase or sale. Surrenders to cover withholding are common for equity compensation and do not necessarily signal a view on the stock. No market-sale or buy transactions were reported here.
Insider Transaction Report
Form 4
BUTLER JOHN C JR
DirectorPresident & CEOOther
Transactions
- Award
Class A Common Stock
[F1][F2][F3]2026-02-17+39,630→ 398,558 total(indirect: By Trust) - Tax Payment
Class A Common Stock
[F4][F2][F3]2026-02-17−8,777→ 389,781 total(indirect: By Trust)
Holdings
- 10(indirect: AMR Associates NC, L.P.)
Class A Common Stock
[F5] - 2,191(indirect: By Trust)
Class A Common Stock
[F6] - 9,052(indirect: By Children)
Class A Common Stock
[F7] - 4,083(indirect: By Trust)
Class A Common Stock
[F8] - 9,208(indirect: By Children)
Class A Common Stock
[F7] - 3,927(indirect: By Trust)
Class A Common Stock
[F8] - 67,482(indirect: By Trust)
Class A Common Stock
[F9] - 2,800(indirect: By IRA)
Class A Common Stock
[F10] - 4,054(indirect: By Trust)
Class A Common Stock
[F11] - 4,055(indirect: By Trust)
Class A Common Stock
[F12] - 1,022(indirect: AMR Associates NC, L.P.)
Class B Common Stock
[F2][F5]→ Class A Common Stock (1,022 underlying) - 7,857(indirect: By Trust)
Class B Common Stock
[F2][F6]→ Class A Common Stock (7,857 underlying) - 26,161(indirect: By Spouse)
Class B Common Stock
[F2][F13]→ Class A Common Stock (26,161 underlying) - 42,529(indirect: By Spouse)
Class B Common Stock
[F2]→ Class A Common Stock (42,529 underlying) - 9,195(indirect: By Trust)
Class B Common Stock
[F2][F9]→ Class A Common Stock (9,195 underlying)
Footnotes (13)
- [F1]Shares of Class A Common Stock awarded to the Reporting Person under the Company's Executive Long-Term Incentive Compensation Plan.
- [F10]Held in an Individual Retirement Account for the benefit of the Reporting Person.
- [F11]Reporting Person's spouse serves as trustee of the JCB 2020 GST Trust for the benefit of Clara R. Butler.
- [F12]Reporting Person's spouse serves as trustee of the JCB 2020 GST Trust for the benefit of Griffin B. Butler.
- [F13]Represents the Reporting Person's spouse's proportionate limited partnership interests in shares held by Rankin Associates I, L.P.
- [F2]N/A
- [F3]Reporting Person serves as Trustee of the J.C. Butler, Jr. Revocable Trust.
- [F4]Cashless Exercise-Award shares that Reporting Person surrendered to Company in order to satisfy his/her tax withholding obligations with respect to his/her Long-Term Incentive Plan Stock Award.
- [F5]Represents the Reporting Person's spouse's proportionate limited partnership interest in shares held by AMR NC. Reporting Person disclaims beneficial ownership of all such shares.
- [F6]Held by BTR 2020 GST Trust for the benefit of Reporting Person's spouse. Reporting Person disclaims beneficial ownership of all such shares.
- [F7]Represents the Reporting Person's child's proportionate limited partnership interests in shares held by Rankin Associates II, L.P . Reporting Person disclaims beneficial ownership of all such shares.
- [F8]Held by Trust, John C. Butler, Jr., Trustee, for the benefit of Reporting Person's minor child. Reporting Person disclaims beneficial ownership of all such shares.
- [F9]Held by Trust for the benefit of Reporting Person's Spouse. Reporting Person disclaims beneficial ownership of all such shares.
Signature
/s/ Matthew J. Dilluvio, attorney-in-fact|2026-02-18